Bakeries Bakeries Search | Advanced Search | New Members | Coupons and Discounts | All Categories Sort alphabetically by... Name City Cookies N' Cream _ 7323 Amboy RoadStaten Island, NY 10307 Theresa Enea (917) 690-7728 Member Since: 2025 COOKIES AND ICE CREAM Learn More | View on Google Maps Crumbl Cookies _ 2955 Veterans Road WestStaten Island, NY 10309 Aimee Tarantino (929) 269-1177 Member Since: 2023 Cookie bakery Learn More | Visit Site | View on Google Maps Holtermann's Bakery _ Holtermann's Bakery Inc.405 Arthur Kill RoadStaten Island, NY 10308 Albert Holtermann (718) 984-7095 Member Since: 1961 At Holtermann's, we are focused on providing fresh, delicious, baked goods with the highest levels of customer satisfaction, we will do everything we can to meet your expectations. With a variety of offerings, we’re sure you’ll be happy. Learn More | Visit Site | View on Google Maps Problem Baker _ 870 Castleton AvenueStaten Island, NY 10310 Nawal Rashed (916) 271-7000 Member Since: 2025 At Problem Baker, we believe that cookies should be the highlight of your day. With the highest quality ingredients, premium real butter, and an incredible variety of flavors, Problem Baker has something for everyone. Learn More | Visit Site | View on Google Maps The Cake Chef _ The Cake Chef957 Jewett AvenueStaten Island, NY 10314 Maria Carrozza (718) 448-1290 Member Since: 2002 We are a small retail bakery located in Staten Island, NY. We bake in small batches to insure freshness. The ingredients used are delivered fresh daily to ensure a high quality product. Learn More | Visit Site | View on Google Maps If your business isn't here, contact us today to get listed!